Skip to main content

tv   The Lead With Jake Tapper  CNN  May 9, 2024 1:00pm-2:00pm PDT

1:00 pm
has been set aside. >> you may be entitled to a portion of that money all when 8085920400. that's when 8085920400 back now to our special coverage, a former president trump's hush money trial. it has been a full day of testimony from several witnesses. the most heated exchanges coming after adult film actress stormy daniels took the stand for a second day. >> she sparred with trump's defense team over her credibility, her motivations, also her work in the adult film industry, daniels testimony was followed by that of a bookkeeper from the trump organization, rebecca mano qio testifying she sent trump's personal checks to the white house for him to sign, and it was her understanding that trump is the only person who could sign his personal checks finally, we heard from a former white house gatekeeper whose desk was just outside the oval office. during trump's presidency, madeline western out on the stand, continuing emotional moment here just ad moments ago as she recounted
1:01 pm
her departure are fine hiring from the white house. thank you so much for joining us. cnn's special coverage of this trial continues now with jake tapper on the lead cnn's breaking news welcome to the lean object tapper in manhattan, just outside the new york criminal courthouse that's where i spend much of the day inside forum number 59 watching witnesses, including stormy daniels testifying the donald j. trump hush money cover up. proud. they have moved on to other there witnesses since stormy daniel's including madeline western out, who's desk was right outside trump's oval office today's testimony is due to end at any moment. >> oh, it just has ended for the day. >> i'm told. well, this hour i'm going to walk you through what i saw, what i sketched, what comes next, the highly skilled courtroom sketch artists it's christine cornell, whose work you're going to look at right now and jane rosenburg, they set the scene today as trump's lawyers cross-examined porn star and director stormy daniels. there clear objective. the defendant its attorneys, to demolish her
1:02 pm
credibility by suggesting the encounter never happened and she made it all up for money. trump reportedly was seething over daniels testimony from tuesday, according to cnn's kaitlan collins, the angles revealed embarrassing details tuesday about the alleged sexual encounter and it's hotel room at a lake tahoe golf tournament in 2006 the annulus on tuesday, even suggested that while the sex was consensual, she did not want to do it and she regretted it so trump wanted to undermine her today. and remember that the judge has threatened trump himself with jail time if he violates his gag order. again, not by talking about any of the witnesses. so his attorneys rather, we're the ones that went after her today before the judge leaves the bench today, we are expecting the defense to raise several issues she's including a renewed motion for mistrial and challenges to the gag order. cnn chief legal affairs correspondent paula reid is here along with jeremy saland, a former saland for former prosecutor for the
1:03 pm
manhattan da's office. while we watch for the defense motion it's to play out. let me help you understand a little bit more about what it's like to be inside that trial. i was your eyes and ears inside the courtroom. i made this little diagram just so you understand what the courtroom is like. it's about 25, 30 foot high ceilings, pretty high ceilings. this is where the spectators sit. five spectators from the public are allowed and they'd get up very, very early in the crack of dawn to get one of those five seats, these blue dots are cops and they are throughout. in fact, if you if you have bad luck, you might not see anything other than the backside of a police officer for much of the court proceedings, this is the most important stuff though. this is the front of the court. all right. >> this is where the jury is. each one and the pink thing is a screen. each one of the jurors has their own screen where they can zoom in on the actual exhibits and evidence. this is where the witness sits. the witness, by the way, sits like the judges stand is like up here, like you considered the witness stand and maybe
1:04 pm
even barely see the judge this is where the lawyer who is conducting either the cross or the redirect stands so you can theoretically come in when you comment over here if you're a witness, you walk in over here. it is possible to never make eye contact with donald trump, who's the t over here. so stormy daniels talking to the attorneys, whether defense or prosecution here here the district attorney is there. mr. trump's sitting here, the judge here, stenographer here. mr. trump, as far as i could tell, and this was my seat. i'm did not have a great seat over here as far as i could tell, he was just looking this way the entire time. that stormy daniels was testifying, which meant that he could be looking at a screen here, a screen they're staring off into space. he did not appear to be looking directly at new witness anyway, that is what the diagram is like. you agree with sur you were present i did this poster, boy. well, you know, i have i know a guy so renaissance man supposed to
1:05 pm
work presentation, but i just never understood that why, why is it that story daniels would have to crane her neck to look at donald trump. >> okay. because she's over here like now i understood it today. anyway, i'll be auction this off $0.50 so, let's talk more about the trial appall the defense. >> the motions, or we're told her about to begin in about ten minutes and the defense is going to move for a mistrial. >> they're taking a short break right now. the defense is going to move for mr. now, why they already did this, the other de there were not successful, but this is important to do to preserve this war and eventual appeal if this doesn't go the way that they had hoped they want to have this on the record, that they moved for a mistrial the last time they argued for mistrial, they argued that stormy daniels testimony was prejudicial, that it just went are outside the bounds of what is relevant in this case. >> we also expect when she was suggesting, by the way, that while it was consensual, she kinda felt pressured. >> that was one of the things that they objected to. >> that is prejudicial. yeah. i would've been that's why we had to listen to an extended a
1:06 pm
continuation of the cross earlier today because they believed that she did reputational damage and they had to repair that. they believe not only for the public, but also for their client who was willie ticked off? so they're also going to argue against karen mcdougal testify now, according to my sources, we don't actually expect karen mcdougal to testify at this point in the case. what they're going to argue along this same lines, they're going to argue that any testimony she would offer will also be outside anything that is material in this case. and they are going to again, they're going to argue that motion as well. but at this point, she's not actually expected to take jeremy. there was another thing today that was interesting. so it's a very beginning of court today, the defense attorney susan nicholas. nicholas, suggested that they wanted to introduce the fact that stormy daniels been arrested, and judge merchan was like, no he literally said something like anybody can be arrested. the question is what she convicted. but he said something like, you could go outside the courtroom today and get arrested. it
1:07 pm
doesn't mean anything which was, an interesting thing to hear a judge say but she wasn't convicted. but then later on in the trial, when they were trying to degrade her credibility, stormy daniels and i talked about the fact that she had some show that had something to do with the paranormal or a podcast or something. i don't know. i'm not really up on her oeuvre. >> but anyway, but, but something about like occupant, like she and her husband and a house and orleans and maybe it was haunted, although she admitted that it was actually a raccoon let's for entertainment, i think she said anyway, and they were trying to say like stormy daniels, your gryffindor, that's basically what they're suggesting without using the word euro graft or you're telling people that you can communicate with their dead relatives. >> you can't baba. and then again, tried to inter inter inserts into the, testimony that the reason that this arrest whatever this arrest was for something to do with her. now, ex husband, and again, the judge no, you can't do that, slapping it down. >> what was that? just a little
1:08 pm
elbow. what was it? what's up to dirty, you're up as best as they could and they went a little too far there. they're beating up this woman, making sure she works in sex. >> she doesn't tell the truth. the sex wasn't real in the porn movies of 150 she made, although she did a really great, dropped 200 movies. and those 50 compilations, she said she wrote or directed 150. it might be, please do not give her career shorts wrote. this is very true, but she responded right? >> which those were as real as it what happened to me that night to your question about the arrest, the rest isn't appropriate. but anyone could be arrested 100%. a conviction is quite different. conviction is absolutely different. and within reason, some convictions wouldn't even come in if they're gone. they ten years and not relevant to what's going on here are credibility. so there were absolutely trying to take as many shots as they could. one of the problems is when you have a client who's looking in anger and looking in engineers really trying to pummel and pulverize that does not always play well for the jury and they pay well for politics outside the courtroom, but not necessarily in a jury. for client service inside the
1:09 pm
courtroom. >> donald trump is mad and they're like, look, you don't have to please don't attacker will do it, right? >> this is what happened it's not helpful. >> that's what this was this morning, right. because on tuesday we saw his first outburst audibly cursing. he was admonished by the judge. and it's clear that they don't want to violate the gag order. they don't want another outburst. >> so they did what he wants to do, which is attacker everything from the indictment, candles right to her career and adult films, to the paranormal, a pawsome, they covered it all in the hopes that that would appease their client and keep them in line. >> because right now, jail is a possibility if you violate the gag order, can be thrown terms around like indictment candles are poor. audience has not been brought up to speed if the fact that there is some store that sells a store, a saint st. stormy daniels those indictment candle will tell you about that in a bit, but trump's defense team went to great lengths to paint her as this opportunist drifter, et cetera, who gained publicity, made a lot of money off what they said was a nonexistent sexual encounter with trump. they pointed to many things including here's the list the non-disclosure
1:10 pm
agreement, the nbc documentary a book contract, merchandise, and there's there's your indictment candle, not my well, not yet. >> i'll buy you one strip the strip club tour, which they mentioned and showed the pictures of many times it's the make america horney again tour and stormy kept saying i hated that title, i hated the title and then they'd bring up a instagram post of her. >> she didn't want the scantily clad with the make america horny again reality show, the paranormal tv show. >> now she says, she yes, she made money off of trump, but it also cost her here's here's the merchant, there's the indictment candle on the rights as it's a comic book, the stormy daniels political power, the hashtag scheme. team stormy. there's, there's, there's the murder. we're talking about, but their point is she made it up and she's making money. do you think that the jury what you're shaking your head? yes. i'm shaking my head because she said at the end it was a net loss to hurt, she didn't make all that money. >> it's a net loss or incident
1:11 pm
lost or her emotionally or safety but this is sort of a sideshow. this is we had remember we had the doorman who had a complete total fabricated story. i think it was 30,000. he got paid. >> if this is somewhat irrelevant, it's what this is important too is what was donald trump's and tests, what was his motile a motive doesn't have to be proven, and it was to help and fix the election and shut her down. so what she made and what she did it's really not that central to the case. in fact, arguably, though i think it's important she was there, they should have had her off as quickly as possible and be done with their good defense? yes. because other thing other than trying to make her to be exploitive, blackmailing yad actor okay. i get that. i get that, but then you according the risk of bleeding are up too much and alienating the jury about a woman who again came from a single mother who was it a question? top graduate high school class. who's made a life for herself, maybe not the one you were. i would want, but she was in a room with the former president or at the time possible president but he was much younger then a man of power and money and choose 20 something years old. >> we got a lot more to go
1:12 pm
through and we're still waiting for the lawyers. they just went back into the courtroom for these motions to dismiss and more stick around as i said, donald trump has seemed just walked in. we're waiting for the defense to raise several issues with the judge. now the testimony is rafah the day and the jury has been dismissed. could a renewed motion to mistrial impact the case will the judge consider changes to trump's gag order to defense attorneys who have previously both work with mr. trump will join us next day with us how we'd really happen with jesse l. martin. sunday's at nine on cnn on the left, your mouthwash with the burning sensation in on the right closest the alcohol-free gentle mouth that works without the burn closest mouthwashes fresh and breadth improve gum health, and strengthened team closest works without the burn? go to one 800 fox, find the perfect giffey. >> people you love whether you want to say. so. q. are logging
1:13 pm
working of you who don't want to under farms that canal rate the people you love this is a future. go daddy arrow creates a logo website, even social posts and minix ai ai like it who wants to come see the future, get your business online in minutes with go daddy arrow to temper pedigrees makes sleep, feel cool. so no more sweating all night or blasting the air conditioning because the timber breeze feels up to ten degrees cooler all night long for a limited time, save up to $500 on select temper p-adic adjustable mattress sets today, at america's beverage companies are bottles might still look the same, but they can be remade in a whole new way thanks to you. we're getting bottles back and we've developed a way to make new ones from 100% recycled plastic new bottles made using no new plastic. >> you'll be seeing more of these bottles in more places. >> and when we get more of them back we can use less new plastic.
1:14 pm
>> bottles are made to be remade for over 25 years, loved sack has been rewriting the rules of comfort. >> it's okay to change your style. >> get messy yet immersed with love's sack. >> you make the rules ego, the number one rated brand in cordless outdoor power brings you the select cut mower, customize the cut with three interchangeable blades. >> it cuts for over an hour on a single charge. >> ego exclusively lows as and ego authorized dealers we can carousel my tiny patches. >> she's improving the look of her fungus damage nail while she's only carousel patches work for up to eight hours to reduce this coloration and thickness. >> now, that's what i call dudi sleep. >> tarasoff nighttime patches. >> we've got you covered
1:15 pm
sandals. >> your mega sales. now odd with race from 1909 per person per night, these its sandals.com or call one 800 sandals if you think you have to patreons contraction, there's a simple test. >> you can take from anywhere. tried to lay her hand flat against the surface if you can, you may have duper trends, contracture, talk to a hand specialists about your options including non-surgical treatments brand that's how you make like it never even happened serve for you for gentle, dependable, constipation really tries seneca. >> it works differently than other laxatives because it's made from the center flat and natural vegetable accident
1:16 pm
radiant gentle, dependable, seneca, also available in delicious gummies. >> close captioning brought to you by meso book.com her firm only represents mesothelial of victims and their families. if you or a loved one has been diagnosed with mesothelioma carlos. now welcome back. >> we have some breaking news. we are back outside the courthouse is donald trump's criminal hush money cover up. trial is underway in the big building time mean the defense is now raising several issues with judge juan merchan, including a mistrial motion. i want to bring in former trump attorney jim trusty in manhattan criminal defense trial attorney stacey schneider, who was also a contestant on on the apprentice strom. she knows the judge, he knows prosecutors in this case so right now, there are motions going on in court, but the breaking news and the reason we did the breaking news thing at the top of this block is we were just told by todd blanche in court, he announced that the
1:17 pm
prosecution has informed the defense they do not intend to call karen mcdougal as a witness. karen mcdougal, 1998 playmate of the year who has alleged relationship with mr. to trump around that same time from 2006 to 2007. and also was the recipient allegedly of hush money in the form of payment for a column she was supposed to write for some fitness magazine published by david pecker's tabloid empire any in any case, i mentioning this because that was the theoretical basis for calling her. but jim trusty, let me get your reaction to this news at prosecution has said, we're not going to call karen mcdougal after all. >> yeah. they just avoided self-immolation. i mean, really, even if they had an inclination to call all her and have yet another credibility fight on their hands probably although maybe not as bad as stormy's. the harvey weinstein reversal is a reminder that new york state courts, like many, frown on other offense evidence. in other words, uncharged conduct being brought into a charged case. so
1:18 pm
mcdougal would have been a silver bullet on appeal for the defense if she testified. and i suspect somebody at the da's office said, guys, whether you want to or not you just can't put her on. it's going to bring it back in a new york minute as so do you agree with that, stacey and do you think that this is a decision specifically made because of that weinstein ruling a few weeks ago this is a distinction with the weinstein ruling, and that the other acts and events that were brought into the weinstein case, were unrelated to the rapes he was charged with in the trial. this is different here because there was this is molyneux new york. what we call molineaux material. it shows an alleged pattern or scheme by a defendant so the reason why the prosecution why these people are called in because karen mcdougal was not part of the criminal charges. the underlying criminal charges for the falsifying business records
1:19 pm
exception, the reason that the catch and kill was brought in through david pecker, through keith davidson the lawyer for stormy daniels and karen mcdougal was to show that trump was allegedly involved in this scheme or pattern of hashing this information before the election. i think that's a very important distinction with the weinstein appeal ruling and doesn't have place here. and i also think not having karen mcdougal in the case is a good decision because i think stormy daniel's was damaging and off with all of the tawdry sex allegations and what went on in that hotel room. i don't think having another woman come in who is alleged to have had a year long affair with donald trump, is going to help the defense case in any way. i think there needs to do more damage control from stormy daniels. >> interesting, jim, i want to get your reaction to a post on twitter from former, former federal prosecutor. renato mariotti. he says, quote trump
1:20 pm
is his lawyers worst enemy, the smart strategy would have been to stipulate that the encounter with daniel's took place, so there would be no reason for her to testify instead, they're heating his wish going after her heart and cross-examination . jurors, what like it unquote what do you think of that and what did have been possible just to stipulate? the mr. trump's stipulates that he met stormy daniels and she alleges something and he disagrees. but either way, he didn't want the story out there. i mean, could that have been stipulated even if without acknowledging something he didn't want to acknowledge what you can stipulate almost anything but both parties have to agree great. i'm not convinced that bragg's office was poised to agree to some kind of equivocating stipulation involving stormy daniels. look jake, i mean, you know, from having me on from the beginning, i've said focus all attention on michael cohen that where you want this battle from the defense is on the issue of whether michael cohen and michael cohen alone can be believed enough to support a criminal conviction. i will tell you. i did change a little
1:21 pm
bit in terms of some of the cross-examination about stormy daniels. i don't think she'd comes off as cleanly as some of your folks are suggesting as she came off as a griffindor i've talked to a lot of dead people and they say they've never talked to stormy but, but look, the bottom line is she was doing some some pretty manipulative things and then pretending that the nda was somehow a protective measure instead of a money grab. i don't think common sense new york jurors are going to buy that. so i kind of retreat from my original instinct to be very minimalist and saint with stormy, which is consistent with the stipulation idea. and i think they probably scored some points, but you have to be in there and watch it blow by blow to know whether the jury he's really feeling feeling the pain right now in the courtroom. >> we should just bring you up to speed. the prosecutor is arguing that modifying the gag order to allow mr. trump's to respond to some of the things witnesses are saying would quote, signal to future witnesses that they could be at risk as well as, you know,
1:22 pm
stacy, one of the things that the defense attorneys have been arguing is that michael cohen is out there hammering donald trump all the time and it's not fair that donald trump can't respond because their argument is this is political speech, political debate. and that is the argument going on i want to bring up stacey, more of what happened today because look at what happened when trump's attorneys asked about the sexual encounter, the alleged sexual encounter between donald trump and stormy daniels, the defense attorney says, quote this wasn't the first time in your life someone made a pass at you? stormy daniels? no. but it is the first time they had a bodyguard standing outside the door. danielson added the trump trump trump was twice her age and bigger than her. again, we talked about this earlier one of the things that makes donald trump so mad. one of the things that the judge seemed so irritated by on tuesday was this insinuation by stormy daniels and i'm not saying it wasn't it's not true, but this insinuation that while it was sent consensual sex, she
1:23 pm
didn't want to do it and she felt pressured. even though she says it was consensual. she's not consensual. she's not claiming she wasn't doesn't that come pretty close to the same thing? what she just said? >> you know, i have a different take on the testimony, just looking at her words, being someone who actually defends sexual assault cases i took her testimony as she was very clear that it was kinda like an ill factor like i didn't really want to have sex with donald trump, but i was in that experience. and how did i get myself into this position? and i just kinda did it and it was more of an emotional thing that i didn't want to do it, but i don't think in any point in her testimony, she came across as this was a nonconceptual act. this was no, no, no, of course. >> right. but there is but there's a line between bloke, there's a wide line between rape, which no one is alleging. right. & falling in love and the et cetera. >> et cetera. >> and like, she was definitely
1:24 pm
saying, oh, my god, how did i get into myself into this situation? i got it. i can't believe i have to go do this right. >> but i think there was a big tactical mistake by the defense team because when you have a bad witness, stormy daniels is a bad witness for the defense. she's testifying to bad and embarrassing facts he doesn't want his denied this sexual allegations. he doesn't want that out in court stormy daniels is going to have the last word if donald trump does not testify about whether or not there was a sexual encounter so you can see he forced his lawyers to go in there and ask these extra questions. most defense attorneys would not have gone back and touch what happened in that hotel room in two seconds they would have just focused on her prior inconsistent statement from january of 2018 where she said this didn't happen. >> interesting stuff. stacey schneider and jim trusty. thank you so much, jim. next time you're having a say on say hi to ben franklin for me happening right now, the court is going through several motions from trump's legal team, the jury has been in
1:25 pm
dismissed for the day we're following it all. we're going to squeeze in a quick break, stay with us businesses good. >> but what if you still can't stay ahead of your bills bus to credit help you stay on top of your expenses and keep the cushion you need to succeed you have what it takes is two credits helps you get the funding you need, whatever your business needs, vista, print and print it. yeah, this sprint, like rachel need to fund packaging so visible are designed to print a new stickers, tape and thank you cards orlean ducky. he didn't get their brand out there so they print a new t-shirts, bottles, and cats. and tasha well, she needed a total refresh, so mr. brown made her a new logo and that that that all that because with vista print, the principalities are endless print it all with 25% off for new customers at vista print.com type two diabetes, discover the ozempic tries zone i got power of three, i learned my a1c cdi risk and lost some
1:26 pm
weight and studies the majority of people reached an a1c under seven and maintained it. >> i'm under seven ozempic lottery where's the risk of major cardiovascular events such as stroke, heart attack, or death in adults, also with known heart disease. i'm laura, my wrist adults lost up to 14 pounds or lost weight. >> i was epic. isn't for people with type one diabetes, don't share needles or pens or reuse needles, don't take those epic if you or your family ever had medullary thyroid cancer or have multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type-2 or the allergic doing. stop ozempic and get medical help right away. if you get a lump or swelling in your neck, severe stomach pain, or an allergic reaction, serious side effects may include pancreatitis, gallbladder problems may occur until your provider about vision problems are changes taking ozempic with a sulfonylurea or insulin may increase low blood sugar risk side effects like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea may lead to dehydration, which may worsen kidney problems living with type two diabetes. >> us about the power of three with ozempic once retired, mark is decided, i will never again work for another man or woman. >> i abandoned my corporate phone plan and i'll get a new
1:27 pm
plan with consumers cellular for up to half the cost, less coburn. when freedom calls, we're here to answer salon pass light again, flex a super thin flexible batch with maximum otc strength lidocaine that contours to the body to relieve pain right where it hurts and did we mention it really, really sticks salon pass. it's good medicine everyday. >> cas, this mother's day help mom take it in stride with thoughtful gifts from weather tech, from playing in the rain with muddy cleats on the floor line to dirty camping reminders in the cargo liner. it's monkey toddlers testing out the all-purpose epic food fights contained by the sea protect at a cup phone the cure her phone. and just like that made mom's life easier, order. >> these american-made products and they're all coming? those who are still with us, yes. grandpa! what's this? your wings.
1:28 pm
light 'em up! gentlemen, it's a beautiful... ...day to fly. feel like time has my back join me a chance. and.com, i'm on rajiv and capitol hill. >> this is sienna & we're back
1:29 pm
live with our breaking news coverage of donald trump's criminal hush money trial. right now, trump's lawyers are raising several motions to judge juan merchan, including that mr. trump should quote, be allowed to respond publicly unquote to stormy daniels testimony, joining me right outside the courthouse adjacent my seat here. cnn's paula reid and kristen holmes so first of all, let's talk about this, paula, because if the gag order mr. trump's under is meant for him to not talk about those who are testifying. why not allowing him to respond to stormy daniels now that she's done, i mean, he can't intimidate her anymore. right? they can't they're not going to call her back. >> this always possibility. so that's why you don't want to open that door there. i think the bigger question is, why not gag everyone involved in this case? because there are some questions it's about more so michael cohen attacking trump, but stormy daniels has of course, attacked him in the past. >> but i want to note that in the last litigation they had a gag order for additional violations that prosecutors alleged. >> there were two having to do with the tax on michael cohen and the judge said that for
1:30 pm
both of those, the prosecutors had not proved beyond a reasonable doubt that those were not protected political speech, right out the door open just a little bit. he's not going to amend the gag order, but he's saying, look, i get that at some point if you're being attacked, you can respond. >> yeah, he seemed to kind of grant there without officially declaring it open season on michael cohen? yeah. yeah. >> and trump, we have to note tuesday, wednesday, thursday has not gone after stormy daniels know and we are expecting him to go to the cameras here when he leaves the courthouse and roughly the next ten minutes and obviously, we'll wait and see. but i do think when it comes to the gag order, donald trump does not want to violate those gag or there's been a lot of talk about the fact that he's a millionaire, billionaire, that he doesn't need the $10,000 and it'll do what he wants donald trump doesn't want to this monday, so he doesn't want to violate the gag order. the other part of this is that despite the fact that he says that he's like nelson mandela and being politically persecuted doesn't want to actually go to jail the man is a dermatome so the idea that he would be seeking that out. now, we saw what he did yesterday or two days ago when he came out
1:31 pm
and it was almost as though he was following a very tight script. he seemed almost unenthusiastic talking about his campaign out there at the microphones. but you can until he had been briefed on what exactly he could say. and i think you're likely to see the same thing today because again, they don't he does not want to violate the gag order. >> yeah. so one thing, paula, you've been in that courtroom. i've been in the courtroom one of the things that i really struck me today was the dichotomy between the momentous snus of this moment, a former president, potentially the next president the presumptive republican presidential nominee, in a criminal courtroom with serious allegations being made against him and all the weight of that. and this gross and silly and stupid. and in some cases, nickel and dime me, kinda like ticky tax charges. and just the not to say that like he didn't break the law. i have no idea. but i don't know. it just pales
1:32 pm
in comparison to the other cases against him, national security secrets, p insurrection in which he's accused of trying to undermine democracy compared to this stuff, when we're talking about stormy daniels calling him an orange turd that needs to be flushed. it's just it's it's kind of mind-boggling. >> i felt that too at times it lacks the weight of the other cad times. yes so whole time, i told it to be fair, the prosecutors have tried to attach a significant against to it, which is they said this is about election interference. and that is a significant thing. but what they have actually charged is falsifying business records 34 counts, and that's when again, it doesn't feel as wavy, but they are trying to the charging. this is a felony, arguing all of this was done to help his chances 2016, to reframe it as election interference, to give it again, that weight and that half that's what they said in their opening statements, is that what the jury will believe? >> i don't know if it's true
1:33 pm
what he did that he did what he did. he did do it to hide it, at least partially from the public. the question now is whether he did it entirely for the public or for also from alonyal. >> a little bit, kristen trump insiders say trump's former personal assistant, madeline western half, who who's on the stand is potentially a very important witness similar to hope hicks. >> she saw so much when she worked for mr. trump, both on the campaign and at the white house. what do you think? >> i think that she is very significant in the sense that she did see everything. again, we've talked about this before, but this is not a traditional white house. so the idea that a special assistant who's sat outside& for all intensive purposes was doing scheduling or making calls would have this big of a role that's really unprecedented. we hadn't seen that before, but in trump's white house, everything was different. someone like madeline would have had full access to the former president, did have full access. remember, donald trump didn't pick up his own phone to make phone calls or texts at all. he would use people's own who was around them and that included madeline western
1:34 pm
people needed to get in touch with donald trump. they'd often reach out to people like hope hicks or madeline. she was in and out of his office. she saw every single person who was in and out of his office she was making lists of who was visiting at various times and she would have had unprecedented amount of access to the former president in ways that even his own cabinet members wouldn't have had. >> i speaking of a list, the list of people who came in with donald trump, his posse, as it were labeled, as if he was like biggie smalls like that. he walks in he's got senator rick scott of florida is with him. boris epstein, alina habba plus of course, all the lawyers is it important to him to have like a big group of supporters you think we're gonna see like, you know, at least phonic. >> yeah. i particularly given the fact that we saw rick scott, i mean, now we're opening a whole new door of potential people who could come like donald trump wants to look like he has a lot of support, but it's not just one sided. i've also heard that certain people have reached out to trump's team asking if they can come and sit in court
1:35 pm
because they want to show their support. i mean, remember where we are right now. donald trump the republican nominee. there's a chance he could be the next president of the united states. there's a lot of people who want to be on his goods, sayyed, if that is in case to happen, rick scott being one of them, elise stefanik being another one or she's potentially vying to be the maybe vice presidential candidate. so you're going to see people cycling in and out because it's a two-way street. donald trump wants to show that he has support and people want to show that they're giving it to him. >> all right, kristen, thanks so much, paul. i will see you back in a few minutes. that's why i let her having extra just moments ago testimony in the hush money trial from donald trump's former personal assistant, who sat right outside the oval office in earlier, how trump's own written written words were used against him. in trial. we're back with much more from the courthouse. we're going to squeeze in a quick break, stay with us sure. >> i'm a paid actor and this isn't a real company, but there's no way to fake up. work can help your business. >> such talent all over the world world was dopa 10,000 skills. you may not happen house more than 30% of the fortune 500 use upwork because
1:36 pm
this is how we work now the all new temper p-adic adapt actress was designed to help me aches and pains. >> a thing of the past, because only and for material eases your pressure points in a way no other mattress can, for a limited time save up to $500 on select temper p-adic adjustable mattress sets why always the couch doesn't need to get a puppy school, get his little puppet diploma no much ever been spending all this little guy when your questions about life turned into questions about money there's erica, the virtual financial assistant to help you spend save and plan smarter. only from bank of america. what would you like the power to do? >> now, adt professionally installs google nest products. you're all set your home is safe and smarter. >> we're going to miss. >> you can check it on your
1:37 pm
home this system you should go manage your system from virtually anywhere get intelligent alerts, like what a package hey, which has arrived are the most trusted name and home security y as the intelligence of google, you have a home with no worries brought to you by adt e, turn, the music off george feel like, can you get that? george?
1:38 pm
>> can you mute the music? >> all right thank you, george for what your? harvest smart farms in abu dhabi, this a technology enabled agribusiness solving global challenges? we're taking proven methods of farming and decoupling the relationship of food production from climate. and instead mirroring it to technology, energy, and capital sources given its heritage in farming, great infrastructure to build a company and the ability to attract foreign talent of dhabi media a ton of sense for us our aspiration is that were accompanied that this country can be proud of you know, i spent a lot of time thinking about dirt at three in the morning. >> and he time what people don't know. is that not all der is the same. you need dirt with the right kind of
1:39 pm
nutrients. look at this new organic soil from miracle grow everybody should have it, it worked great for us. this is as good as gold in any garden. >> if people only knew that it really is about the dirt, your dirt nerd huge turret i'm proud of it for. >> over 25 years, loved sack has been rewriting the rules of comfort. it's okay to change your style. >> get messy yet immersed with love, sac you make the rules find a great deal for your ideal hutto open trivago typing where you wanna go select your check-in and check-out dates. >> you search compare prices for the same hotel and save up to $30 a night hotel. trivago and we're back outside court as the defense's renewing its motion for mistrial, arguing that prosecutors asked questions they should not have
1:40 pm
related to the alleged sexual encounter between donald trump and stormy daniels in 2006 moments ago, the judge denied donald trump's request. >> that the gag order be modified. mr. trump wanted to be able to respond publicly to the testimony from stormy daniels now that she's done at least for now, that was flatly rejected. cnn chief legal affairs correspondent paula reid is here along with jeremy saland, former prosecutor for the manhattan da's office, and one of the thanks for going over right now, jeremy is the fact that in the view of the defense attorneys, the testimony that came out tuesday with so prejudicial because it suggested that the sex was not consensual, even though stormy daniels said it was consensual she said other things. donald trump was bigger than me. i didn't want to do it the todd blanche the defense attorney, is saying the fact that it was introduced, that there was no condom worn during this acts in
1:41 pm
his view, is a quote, dog whistle for rape. >> how strong a case does he have? >> i think he's going to find themselves in the same position he was when he first made the application. i think the judge is going to deny it one of the things, if you recall, the judge, were shot or dress was you didn't object you in an object. you're only enough get an object often enough and maybe not those exact words, but it's incumbent upon you as it offense to make those representations or objections, part of me. >> that's number one. number two, nothing has changed since that time since that initially argument was made. so i would assume you will sustain this and say no or we're going to proceed with the case, but keep in mind at the end of the people's direct case when they are done, there'll be another application to move for trial, order of dismissal, so it can be renewed yeah. >> and the other thing is that the judge is saying is, you sustained during trial and i mean, you objected during the trial and i sustain those objections. so the jury's already been told to disregard yeah. and they're going to get a limiting instruction. so that was a bit of a win for the trump team. but look, what happened tuesday, this really
1:42 pm
antagonize that the defendant and suggestion that this was not consensual. this was 100% on their minds yesterday, and that's when they decided to go longer in this cross is reported and address this issue because this was something that really upset the defendant arguably has nothing to do with the charges in this case, but this was something that they wanted to address because they believe that it's spoke to reputational damage. so we're not only talking about the courtroom that you in, were talking about the korda public opinion that's part of why they spent so much time on it. >> yeah. so one of the other things, obviously, the defense spent much of the de trying to destroy stormy daniels reputation. one of the things that they talk about is her her different stories over the years and she's been telling the story in different ways since 2006 when an allegedly happened about about the meal that they've suppose he supposedly invited her for and inconsistencies about her story. so the defense pointed to this 2018 interview with anderson cooper. take a listen.
1:43 pm
>> did you to go out for dinner that night you had dinner in the room? yes but but she also said she said you had didn't. >> she says you had dinner in the room there. >> but in court, she said that they had no food, there was no food. now, in response, crumbley testified, we did not have any food. i did not in any food. i maintain that in every interview that is not changed necklace, the defense attorney says when you said to anderson cooper you didn't really mean you had dinner, you meant something else. daniel said we had dinner time in the room. necklace says your words, don't mean what they say do they they, didn't have dinner they did have dinner. >> does it matter. >> so this is a necklace. the point she's making in front of the jury is that we can't believe you you say one thing, then you say another. that's the point that they were trying to get when they spent so much time on the semantic meaning of dinner. and it doesn't really matter again for the facts of the case for falsifying business records. but what she gave prosecutors was an account of what exactly was worth
1:44 pm
$130,000 in october 2016, and they were trying to at a minimum so some doubt about her version of events. >> is that effective? >> i don't think it's that effective. i think what the defense may want to do is make this a sex case because it's not a sex case, the prosecution has to bring it back, that's paul just said it's falsifying business records remember, the doorman lied absolutely lied. there was no other child and you still paid him. this is a falsifying business records. it makes no difference if stormy daniels told you the truth, 50% or live completely because it's not about her. it's not about her. >> so there's another moment, trump's defense team appears to accuse stormy of making the whole story up. they say the defense attorney says, who's nicholas, you have a lot of experience of making phony stories about sex appear to be real. this is a nod to her film career in an adult films. >> she says, wow, that's just not how i would put it. >> the sex and the film's is very much real just like what happened to me in that room now, to be clear, the defense didn't say the sex wasn't real. it was making phony stories about sex. but it
1:45 pm
didn't feel like they score at any points though, only with their client. that's what this was four this was for an audience of one, like make him feel that she was attacked and that he was vindicated we don't violate the gag order or have court outburst. otherwise, not. this does this isn't going to change the outcome of this case. so i wanted to ask you this, jeremie because it does seem to me these are all very effective attorneys and all that. >> but susan necklace, trump's attorney, said to stormy daniels you know, you said that your integral to donald trump going to jail and she said, where did i say that? show me where i said that. and she shows this tweet. it's a tweet from daniels that call falls trump an orange turkey that she's going to flush. daniel said that was in response to someone else's post. so the defense says you are responding to the post, someone else's post there, daniels. yeah, someone calling me a human toilet. so i capitalize on the joke defense. the other posts, michael cohen and stormy daniel's, aka the human toilet, or their star witnesses, right? daniels? yes. defense you said exactly making
1:46 pm
me the best person to flush the orange turd down? daniels. yes. i don't see instrumental or jail. there you're putting words in my mouth i mean she's right she was putting words in their mouth. does that hurt the attorney no i think if you're putting words, they're not accurate and then the prosecution comes back and challenged it effectively, or the defendant or pardon me, the witness challenges that effectively. it makes it look a little sleazy. it makes him look a little bad as an attorney. but again, this is a sideshow. i think part of the argument right here of what the defense is trying to do is make it about stormy daniels, because if you can make it about stormy daniels and you can put some doubt in her and her credibility and a veracity, then you could get them away from what the case is about and not about falsifying business records without a former porn star who's trying to go after the former president all right, fallen jeremie stick around. so judge, juan, were sean has just denied trump's request to modify the gag order so he could come out, right at those fences where you see right there and talk about stormy
1:47 pm
daniels now that her testimony is over at least for now, that request was denied. trump's legal team has also renewing their request for a mistrial based on what they say it was prejudicial information that stormy daniels offered in testimony on the stand. those arguments are happening right now. we're going to squeeze in another quick break we'll be right back we can carousel my tiny patches. >> she's improving the look of her fungus damage now, while she sleeps only carousel patches worked for up to eight hours to reduce this coloration and thickness. >> now that's what i called the ut easley tarasoff nighttime patches we've got you on the left, your mouthwash with the burning sensation in on the right closest the alcohol-free gentle mouthwash that works without the burn, close mouthwashes fresh and breath improve gum health and strengthened team closest works without the burn we put off heart into celebrating moms were local farmers bakers, florist, and makers who grow
1:48 pm
and create with a passion. >> one 800 flowers for mom with love time for growth, funding from bus due credit makes it possible are easy and convenient process makes it simple to take the next step on your journey this to credit funding. >> what's next sentence? >> jamaica saline now with rates from one 19 knife for a person per night, this is sad those.com or call one 800 sandals. ego, the number one rated brand in cordless outdoor power brings you the select cut mower customized to cut with three interchangeable blades. it cuts for over an hour on a single charge ego exclusively lows ace and ego authorized dealers the future is not just going to happen, you have to make it. and if you want a successful business, all it takes is an idea and now becomes a future where you grew
1:49 pm
at into a reality we all know, go daddy arrow, put your business online in minutes with the power of ai for gentle, dependable, constipation really tries seneca, it works differently than other laxative because it's made from the center flat. and natural vegetable active ingredient in gentle, dependable seneca, also available in delicious gummies and the furniture business things move fast. >> ziprecruiter helps us hire qualified candidates who keep up. >> we needed a project manager yesterday, we posted a job and ziprecruiter and had are the guy on-site& five days. he was qualified and everyone ziprecruiter fonts the best candidates for all our jobs and they helped us build our dream team. then he did it fast is that too fast for you out of five employers who post on ziprecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day hi for free at ziprecruiter.com slash higher, they slept on me for 15 years, things like collected pollen, dust, dander, all that time. they could have protected me. >> mallory's mattress
1:50 pm
protectors walk 99.9% of dirt dust, grow your business
1:51 pm
easily with freelancers, supplier were how solomon in new york is cnn we're back with the breaking news, judge merchan, the judge in the new york hush money trial is hearing a series of motions from donald trump's defense team, cnn's kara scannell was just in the courtroom. kara trump's request to modify the gag order so that he could respond to stormy daniels testimony, at least in part, what was denied. tell us about how that went down that sorry, jake. >> so the judge, justin, i'd that motion to modify the gag order and trump's lawyers had said that they wanted at modified because they said that stormy daniels story had changed from what she had initially told in 2018 t.h. through media interviews to what she testified on the stand and they said that in part their allegation is that it changed because she made the suggestion that the her encounter with trump may not have been consensual. a. daniels testified that it was
1:52 pm
consensual, but she also said that she lacked out at one point and that she was surprised and shocked to see trump on the bet in his boxers and a t-shirt. but what trump's lawyers are saying is that in news media on television people including political pundits, were talking about daniels testimony and this change. and they were arguing that trump should have a an opportunity to respond to that. so voters could hear what his response is. prosecutor strongly pushed back about that, saying that they had some witnesses, including some of the witnesses that are brought in to introduce records. so they're called custodial witnesses. they said that some of these witnesses express their own fear and concern about testifying in this trial, and they did not have anything get at stake with donald trump's. so they said that there was still fear. in fact, they said there was fear in the eyes of daniels because on one of the forms, her personal address was listed there. same now at this is very much a real risk and they said that is a risk because it's donald trump's own rhetoric that he continues to make statements
1:53 pm
about people. and they pointed to a statement and that they pulled from an expert of donald trump's book in which he repeatedly has said in a couple of excerpts in eye for an eye and that you should go after someone who comes after you. so the judge agreeing with prosecutors i'm saying that he was not going to modify the gag order to let trump respond to stormy daniels hurt her testimony in the past few days, they're actually currently arguing. again, trump's requests for mistrial. his lawyers are saying again about this testimony that daniels gave some of the details that she's testified about in this trial that she is not publicly said about her concerns about the body guard being at the door. they're saying that all of that is not what was at stake in 2016. it was not the reason why michael cohen would have paid for the story and so they're saying that that actually goes beyond what was supposed to be allowed in this case of prosecutors pushing back on that same daniels hasn't changed for story saying that they weren't careful not to solicit some explicit the details, including more details about their sexual
1:54 pm
encounter and said that they were working to keep her testimony in line with what the judge had said. now, there's judge, i don't believe has yet ruled on this. they've been arguing pretty going back and forth pretty aggressively over this issue. one other issue that trump's lawyer had initially please flag. he wanted to bring up. was that they didn't want karen mcdougal to testify. now, they said that they'd been informed by the prosecutors that she'll would not be taking the stand, so she will not be appearing this case as this is winding down, there's really only one have significant witness less than that is michael cohen but prosecutors have not yet said when they will call him jane that's right. >> it's interesting that the prosecuting attorney, mr. steinglass, i think is his name, said that there are a lot of salacious details. his words that they did not include that they purposely did not include and still we're not in the case and they were not seeking to embarrass mr. trump. i
1:55 pm
suppose that's true at least as far as anybody who's familiar with stormy daniels book or her appearance on jimmy kimmel knows, but still what came out was, i think it's i mean, i can understand the argument that it was prejudicial because she certainly seem to be suggesting that she didn't want it to happen even if it was even if it was not coerced right? >> that is what the heart of their argument is for a mistrial because they say that that went far beyond what daniels had said and it's not what was at stake in 2016 and not what the prosecution theory that trump wanted to keep from the vote voters at that time, because that was a different story according to trump's sayyed, and they've been arguing this, that argue that yesterday, that bringing it up again today and the prosecution is trying to say that she didn't change your story and that necklace. trump's lawyer had an opportunity to ask her questions about that on
1:56 pm
cross-examination. and so the jury would have heard that there's not need for a mistrial& the case does not appear that the judge has ruled on this, yet he did deny the motion yesterday, however all right. >> guys, can you think thanks so much. some rather dramatic moments as court runs a bit late today, the defense team pushing for a mistrial, trying to get parts of the gag order lifted. now that one of the witnesses, stormy daniels, has finished testifying, we're going to we use in a quick break. we'll be right back hey, they're brenda. it's carol exactly. >> so which like are we operating on? >> you mean arm? >> it's all connected, asking the right question can greatly impact your future. >> you share your an orthopedist. >> actually, i'm a sagittarius, especially when it comes to your finances give a question. are us certified financial planner yes. >> i'm a cfp professional cop professials are committed to acting in your best interest. >> that's why it's gotta be a cfb bind your cfp professional, and let's make a plan nauta now, adt professionally
1:57 pm
installs google nest products, cool you're allet our mis system. >> we should go with t the most trusted name and home security as the intelligence of google, you have a home with no worries brought to you by, at whatever your business seems, vista print can print it like packaging for tapes of thank you. >> cards were merged from teachers to caps, even logo that you can put on all that. because with this sprint, the printer it's abilities are endless. new customers get 25% off at misprint.com find a great deal for your ideal hotel opened your vargo typing where you wanna go select your check-in and check-out dates. you search compare prices for the same hotel and save up to $30 a night hotel. trivago. >> what if we don't get down at time to get a birthday gift for zoe, don't panic with at day, we can find the perfect gift and center a preview right away. >> thank sky don't panic. >> you've easy with etsy today at america's beverage
1:58 pm
companies are models might still a look the same, but they can be remade in a whole new way. >> thanks to you we're getting bottles back and we've developed a way to make new ones from 100% cycled plastic, new bottles made using no new plastic you'll be seeing more of these bottles in more places. >> and when we get more of them back we can use less new plastic cr bottles or to be remade got a minute got a hose, want a simple way to save money on yard care. >> how with sunday, the customized lawn care plan that's delivered straight to your doors that he said you bet your grass, it is sunday offers everything you need to get grass. that's good for baer fee and bear pause, no more guessing. just lawn care. that's better for saving money and saving the planet. so ditch the old ways for sunday fun days, go to get sunday.com and use code fund 50 for 50% off your first lombok for over 25 years, loved sack has been
1:59 pm
rewriting the rules of comfort. it's okay to change your style. >> get messy yet immersed with love, sac. you make the rules sure. >> i'm a paid actor and this isn't a real company, but there's no way to fake up. work can help your business. >> such talent all over the world with over 10,000 skills, you may not happen house more than 30% of the fortune 500 ust
2:00 pm
it is clinically back to promote healthy liver function so that nothing is holding you back. >> i'm natasha bertrand at the pentagon and this is cnn cnn breaking news we have breaking news right now. the judge in donald trump's hush money coming rep. is considering several motions for the defense and rule rule at any moment on mr. trump's motion for mistrial the judge has also just denied mr. trump's request to modify his gag order. >> a cnn chief legal affairs correspondent, paula reid is here along